|
Construction Progress
|
|
12/15/04:
The Star Wars flight yoke controller reproduction project started in
late 2004. This is about the same time I started the
Major Havoc roller controller project. Both of these projects
began before I officially opened up RAM controls as a separate
business. Armed with an illustrated parts list for the
controller and a couple of spare controllers (one pictured above), I
set out to reproduce this controller in whole and as accurate to the
original as possible, while trying to also incorporate minor
improvements to extend the lifespan of the reproduction version. |
|
|
06/01/05:
Purchase
of complete hardware line accomplished (screws, nuts, bolts, etc).
Pictured is a small fraction of the total stock. It was
critical that I have a complete selection of hardware before I
attempted any reproduction work. I bought roughly
5,000-10,000pcs each of roughly 450 different size screws, nuts,
washers, etc. Mostly stainless steel and alloy parts.
This took some time to acquire and stock. |
|
07/15/05:
Purchase of special retaining rings completed. Used to retain
handle and steering shafts. Believe it or not, I didn't know
what this retaining ring was called. No, it's not an
E-Clip. Anyhow, after a little time, I was able to find the
OEM for this part and purchased up a big batch to add to my hardware
stock. |
|
08/18/05:
Special I.D./O.D. stainless steel washers stamped out and completed
in-house. Used on steering shaft. This washer was
unavailable no matter where I looked. I finally said the heck
with it and designed my own tooling to stamp these out of stainless
steel sheet metal. They turned out quite nice if I do say so
myself. For the record, I ran off about 5,500 of these. No, we
won't be running out of these anytime soon! |
|
09/01/05:
Large torsion spring run completed in-house. Used in steering
assembly frame. I own spring making machines, so this was a
simple operation. I ran off a great big batch of these, so
we'll have spare springs for years to come. |
|
09/09/05:
Small torsion spring run completed in-house. Used in handle
assembly frame. I own spring making machines, so this was a
simple operation. I ran off a great big batch of these, so
we'll have spare springs for years to come. |
|
09/09/05:
Small compression spring run completed in-house. Used in
handles for thumb buttons and triggers. I own spring
making machines, so this was a simple operation. I ran off a
great big batch of these, so we'll have spare springs for years to
come. |
|
11/20/05:
Special made bronze flange bearing completed. These were an
interesting part to source. I was sure this was actually a
"bushing" not a "bearing" but come to find out,
I was way off. It's a sintered bronze flange bearing.
What a mouthful. Anyhow, I found the OEM who made them for
Atari and had them run off a large order for me. Again, enough
spares for many years to come. |
|
12/05/05:
Neoprene rubber bumper outer part completed. The rubber bumpers
used on the Star Wars yoke are a pain in the backside to
replace. I decided to make some minor design changes that will
allow easy replacement of the rubber part of the bumper when the
time comes. Made from high quality neoprene rubber, no matter
how good it is, it is destined to fail eventually. That's the
nature of rubber components. I was, at least, able to ease the
replacement woes. I was able to produce this part in house
once I sourced the proper rubber material. No shortage of
parts here. |
|
12/09/05:
Rubber bumper inner part completed in-house. This part was
made from a nice steel stock material and machined down to
size. It's a perfect fit for the rubber part pictured above
and the frame assemblies they attach to. The part is slightly
enlarged to help withstand normal and abusive handling. The
OEM part would bend fairly easily under normal use. The
reproduction counterpart should withstand much more force and,
therefore, last much longer. |
|
12/10/05:
Rubber bumper assembly completed. This is what the
assembled rubber bumper looks like. The rubber ring simply
slides onto the metal bumper base. Pretty straight forward
from beginning to end. |
|
02/20/06:
Anchor Pin completed in-house. Made from steel, zinc plated
gold. These were machined from hex steel rod stock and then
put through the screw machine. Once completed, they were given
a nice zinc oxide coating. |
|
05/13/06:
Anchor Nut completed in-house. Made from steel, zinc plated
gold. These were machined from hex steel rod stock and then
put through the screw machine. Once completed, they were given
a nice zinc oxide coating. |
|
12/29/06:
Spring Pin completed in-house. Made from steel, zinc plated
gold. These were machined from round steel rod stock and given
a nice zinc oxide coating. The color variation from part to
part was a result of testing different coating processes. |
 |
01/03/07:
Thumb button completed in-house. Part upgraded to 6061
aluminum. They have not been anodized yet, but we should have
them finished up in two weeks or less. We're going with a
"hard" black anodize which should provide a very tough finish that
looks nice. |
 |
01/10/07: We just
completed a full
production run of 5000 aluminum hubs for the 14-tooth gears. The
hubs are machined 6061 aluminum parts. These are near-perfect
reproduction parts, manufactured to Atari specification. Now
we just need to have the actual Delrin gears injection molded onto
the hubs. |
 |
01/10/07: We just
completed a full
production run of 5000 aluminum hubs for the 28-tooth gears. The
hubs are machined 6061 aluminum parts. These are near-perfect
reproduction parts, manufactured to Atari specification. Now
we just need to have the actual Delrin gears injection molded onto
the hubs. |
 |
01/10/07: We just
completed a full
production run of 5000 aluminum hubs for the 60-tooth gears. The
hubs are machined 6061 aluminum parts. These are near-perfect
reproduction parts, manufactured to Atari specification. Now
we just need to have the actual Delrin gears injection molded onto
the hubs. |
|
01/14/07:
Thumb button completed in-house. Part upgraded to 6061
aluminum and hard anodized black. I don't know how many times
I've come across yokes with worn thumb buttons. I've never
seen a thumb button to the brink of non-functional, but a few were
pretty close. I'm convinced that the aluminum version I've
designed will outlast the OEM part. |
|
01/21/07:
Steering shaft prototype pictured before full production run. Made from
steel and ground to spec. This shows what the part looks like
prior to zinc plating. I happen to prefer this look, but if I
went this way it wouldn't be as close to OEM as possible now would
it? I've had the shafts cut and
ready for machining for a long time now. I finally had the
time to create the program and run them off. I snagged a fresh
milled part (before zinc plating) to get a nice photo for the
website. This part is completely within the original spec, but
the material I chose far exceeds the original specifications. |
|
01/21/07:
Handle shaft prototype pictured before full production run. Made from
steel and ground to spec. This shows what the part looks like
prior to zinc plating. I happen to prefer this look, but if I
went this way it wouldn't be as close to OEM as possible now would
it? I've had the shafts cut and
ready for machining for a long time now. I finally had the
time to create the program and run them off. I snagged a fresh
milled part (before zinc plating) to get a nice photo for the
website. This part is completely within the original spec, but
the material I chose far exceeds the original specifications. |
|
02/09/07: Steering
shaft production part. Made from steel, ground to spec,
machined and zinc plated gold. Here's a picture of the final
production version of the steering shaft. Looks pretty close
to the original. |
|
02/09/07: Handle
shaft production part. Made from steel, ground to spec,
machined and zinc plated gold. Here's a picture of the final
production version of the handle shaft. Looks pretty close to
the original. |
 |
02/10/07:
Steering
Frame Assembly prototype components (flats) pictured just before the
assembly process (forming/bending and welding). Parts are
laser cut from 11 gauge cold rolled steel (CRS).
Note:
Pictured to left is 1 of 2 parts belonging to the "Steering Frame" -
this is the "base" portion of the steering assembly, the part that
mounts the entire yoke controller to the control panel. The
stud fasteners still need to be press fit into the part you see
pictured. |
 |
02/10/07:
Steering
Frame Assembly prototype components (flats) pictured just before the
assembly process (forming/bending and welding). Parts are
laser cut from 11 gauge cold rolled steel (CRS).
Note:
Pictured to left is 2 of 2 parts belonging to the "Steering Frame" -
Atari originally designed this as two separate parts, but with the
advanced CNC press brakes of today, forming this from a single flat
is very easy. |
 |
02/10/07:
Steering
Frame Assembly prototype components (flats) pictured just before the
assembly process (forming/bending and welding). Parts are
laser cut from 11 gauge cold rolled steel (CRS).
Note:
Pictured to left is 1 of 3 parts belonging to the "Handle Frame" -
this is the "base" portion of the handle assembly. The special
"collar" stills needs to be welded into the part you see pictured. |
 |
02/10/07:
Handle
Frame Assembly prototype components (flats) pictured just before the
assembly process (forming/bending and welding). Parts are
laser cut from 11 gauge cold rolled steel (CRS).
Note:
Pictured to left is 2 of 3 parts belonging to the "Handle Frame" -
these form the sides of the yoke controller. The special shape
alone should give it's identify away. |
 |
02/10/07:
Handle
Frame Assembly prototype components (flats) pictured just before the
assembly process (forming/bending and welding). Parts are
laser cut from 11 gauge cold rolled steel (CRS).
Note:
Pictured to left is 3 of 3 parts belonging to the "Handle Frame" -
this part mounts inside the front part of the handle frame. |
 |
02/10/07: Handle
Frame Cover prototype component (flat) pictured just before the
assembly process (forming/bending and welding). Part is laser
cut from 16 gauge cold rolled steel (CRS). This forms the
cover for the entire yoke controller. This is the part that
the yoke overlay is attached to. |
 |
02/17/07 - To the left, we have our earliest Solidworks model of our
prototype handle frame assembly.
The original assembly from Atari was made from 11GA HRP&O (hot
rolled pickled & oiled) which was OK, but our version will be made
from 11GA cold rolled steel which is much stronger/stiffer. |
 |
02/17/07 - To the left, we have our earliest Solidworks model of our
prototype steering frame assembly.
The original assembly from Atari was made from 11GA HRP&O (hot
rolled pickled & oiled) which was OK, but our version will be made
from 11GA cold rolled steel which is much stronger/stiffer. |
|
02/18/07: Handle
Frame Assembly prototype Revision A pictured just before full production
run. We're going to make a Revision B model before the
production run so we can change out some of those pesky OEM issues. Part is made from 11 gauge steel, laser cut, formed to
spec and TIG welded. Note: part has been prepped for powder
coat, which gives it an interesting color/texture and smoothes out
the sharp edges. Also, shaft hub in rear of assembly is made
from steel, machined to spec and welded into place. |
|
02/18/07: Steering
Frame Assembly prototype Revision A pictured just before full production
run. We're going to make a Revision B model before the
production run so we can change out some of those pesky OEM issues. Part is made from 11 gauge steel, laser cut, formed to
spec and TIG/MIG welded Note: part has been prepped for powder
coat, which gives it an interesting color/texture and smoothes out
the sharp edges. Also, #1/4-20 x 5/8" captive studs (self
clinching) pre-installed into frame assembly for form/fit testing. |
|
02/18/07: Handle
Frame Cover prototype pictured just before full production
run. Part is made from 16 gauge steel, laser cut and formed to
spec. Note: part has been prepped for powder coat, which gives
it an interesting color/texture and smoothes out the sharp edges. |
 |
02/20/07:
We just received our order of the self clinching studs used on the
steering assembly base. These are the fasteners that hold the
entire controller to the control panel. We picked up enough of
these for about 4000 controllers. It takes a minimum of 3.5 tons of force
to press fit these fasteners into place. I think we can cover
that....and then some. |
 |
02/23/07:
This is the collar/bushing used on the handle assembly which is the
attachment point for the steering shaft. It's welded into the
back of the handle assembly frame. I just ran off enough of
these for
the first run of 1000 controllers. I have 42 of these trays
full of the collars! Hopefully, this will be
enough to last for a long while! |
 |
02/25/07: Here's
picture number one of the full production run (1000pcs) of sheet
metal parts used to make the steering assembly and handle assembly.
This is what it looks like before they're all bent and welded
together. Nothing really fancy here, just wanted to
demonstrate the magnitude of this project and our commitment to it. These
are mostly 11GA parts with the exception of the handle assembly
cover which is cut from 16GA cold rolled steel. In this
picture, you can see a massive number of the handle frame side
plates. These form the left and right sides of the main
housing seen when using the yoke controller. |
 |
02/25/07: Here's
picture number two of the full production run (1000pcs) of sheet
metal parts used to make the steering assembly and handle assembly.
This is what it looks like before they're all bent and welded
together. Nothing really fancy here, just wanted to
demonstrate the magnitude of this project and our commitment to it. These
are mostly 11GA parts with the exception of the handle assembly
cover which is cut from 16GA cold rolled steel. Three
different parts can be seen in this picture. Up front you can
see the steering frame bracket (the furthest back part of the entire
controller). To the left and slightly back, a part belonging
to the "Handle Frame" is pictured - this part mounts inside the
front part of the handle frame. Along the back/top of the
picture, another part belonging to the "Handle Frame" - this is the
"base" portion of the handle assembly. This is where the
special "collar" (pictured two up) is welded on. |
 |
02/25/07: Here's
picture number three of the full production run (1000pcs) of sheet
metal parts used to make the steering assembly and handle assembly.
This is what it looks like before they're all bent and welded
together. Nothing really fancy here, just wanted to
demonstrate the magnitude of this project and our commitment to it. These
are mostly 11GA parts with the exception of the handle assembly
cover which is cut from 16GA cold rolled steel. A closer view
of the previous picture. You can get a better view of how deep
these stacks of parts really are. |
 |
02/25/07: Here's
picture number four of the full production run (1000pcs) of sheet
metal parts used to make the steering assembly and handle assembly.
This is what it looks like before they're all bent and welded
together. Nothing really fancy here, just wanted to
demonstrate the magnitude of this project and our commitment to it.
One part in particular can be seen in this picture. You can
see the handle frame cover (on the right side of the picture) which is the only 16 gauge part we had to
cut for this project. Particular attention was paid to the
corners (which are slightly rounded on the reproduction version) and
the hole placement (which is off by up +/- 0.060" on the OEM parts
made by Atari). Ours are within 0.001" tolerances which may be
considered overkill for sheet metal parts, but the yoke project
deserves no less than perfection. |
 |
02/27/07: Here's
picture number one which shows a sampling of the full production run
(1000pcs) of steering assembly plates. Note the press-fit
fasteners in the plate. We used a 20-ton hydraulic press to
fit these into place. |
 |
02/27/07: Here's
picture number two which shows a sampling of the full production run
(1000pcs) of steering assembly brackets. Note the main design
change. Atari originally had this part as two pieces welded
together. With our much more advanced equipment and precise
cutting technology, we were able to create this bracket from a
single piece of sheet metal formed into place. |
 |
02/27/07: Here's
picture number three which shows a sampling of the full production
run (1000pcs) of handle assembly plates. Note the main design
change here. Essentially, "slots" were cut into the tabs to
allow easy tool access to the set screws on the collar. Then,
of course, all corners were rounded to decrease the likelihood of
sustaining an accidental cut which is never fun. |
 |
02/27/07: Here's
picture number four which shows a sampling of the full production
run (1000pcs) of handle assembly brackets. The only real
design change here was the larger radius on the corners. Aside
from this, it's identical to the OEM counterpart. |
 |
02/27/07: Here's
picture number five which shows a sampling of the full production
run (1000pcs) of handle assembly covers. The only real design
change here was the larger radius on the corners. Of course,
we also paid close attention to the placement of the holes, as well.
I'm not sure that would be considered a design "change". Aside from
these notes, it's identical to the OEM counterpart. |
 |
03/06/07: Here we
have a sample of our TIG welded
handle assembly. This would be considered "Revision B" with
obvious modifications from the OEM and our initial Revision A
version. |
 |
03/06/07: Here we
have a 10pc sample of our TIG welded
steering assemblies. This would be considered "Revision B" with
obvious modifications from the OEM and our initial Revision A
version. The OEM steering frame assembly was a three-piece
design. Ours is a two-piece design which does make for a
better part. Modern CNC press brakes allow this modification
to be possible. |
|
03/20/07: Full
production run 60-tooth gears. The gears are made from cast
Delrin with machined aluminum hub. These are near-perfect
reproduction parts, manufactured to Atari specification, with
upgraded materials. |
|
03/20/07: Full
production run 28-tooth gears. The gears are made from cast
Delrin with machined aluminum hub. These are near-perfect
reproduction parts, manufactured to Atari specification, with
upgraded materials. |
|
03/20/07: Full
production run 14-tooth gears. The gears are made from cast
Delrin with machined aluminum hub. These are near-perfect
reproduction parts, manufactured to Atari specification, with
upgraded materials. The original gears made by Atari were
press-fit. This is one of the reasons why the originals fail
so badly. Ours are insert molded (or over-molded) when
relieves the stress of the plastic gear being mated with the metal
hub. Plus, the type of knurling we use will give the plastic
more strength to hold together. Anyhow, the final decision was to go for
"purity" with this component rather than a fully
redesigned part which is why we stuck with plastic/metal like the
original. The diehard SW fans should appreciate this. It
LOOKS like the original part, but it's so much better. |
 |
04/15/07: New
order of Cherry snap action switches has arrived. We have
enough of these for a few thousand controllers. We'll include
these in the upcoming rebuild kits, too. |
 |
06/01/07:
I've put
together some yoke "rebuild kits" to help service the OEM crowd who
are obviously in need of replacement parts for their current
machines. The first rebuild kit, called the "standard" version
will include all of the following parts: (4) Rubber Bumpers,
(2) Thumb Buttons, (4) Small Compression Springs, (4) Snap-Action
Switches, (2) 60-Tooth Gear, (1) 28-Tooth Gear, (1) 14-Tooth Gear
Update 11/17/07:
I'm also including the following item in this kit as of today: (2)
"Extra Life" Precision 5K Potentiometers. Picture updated to
include new components.
Update 11/08/09: I'm also including the following items in
this kit as of today: (1) Spacer Bearing, (1) Tube Nyogel 779ZC.
Picture updated to include new components. |
 |
06/01/07: The next
level of rebuild kit, called the "deluxe" version will include all
of the following parts: (4) Rubber Bumpers,
(2) Thumb Buttons, (4) Small Compression Springs, (4) Snap-Action
Switches, (2) 60-Tooth Gears (1) 28-Tooth Gear, (1) 14-Tooth Gear, (2)
Large Torsion Springs, (2) Small Torsion Springs.
Update 11/17/07:
I'm also including the following item in this kit as of today: (2)
"Extra Life" Precision 5K Potentiometers. Picture updated to
include new components.
Update 11/08/09: I'm also including the following items in
this kit as of today: (1) Spacer Bearing, (1) Tube Nyogel 779ZC.
Picture updated to include new components. |
 |
06/01/07: The top
level of rebuild kit, called the "premium" version will include all
of the following parts: (4) Rubber Bumpers,
(2) Thumb Buttons, (4) Small Compression Springs, (4) Snap-Action
Switches, (2) 60-Tooth Gears, (1) 28-Tooth Gear, (1) 14-Tooth Gear, (2)
Large Torsion Springs, (2) Small Torsion Springs, (4) Flange Bearings, (1)
Steering Shaft, (1) Handle Shaft, (1) Anchor Pin, (1) Anchor Nut, (1)
Spring Pin.
Update
11/17/07: I'm also including the following item in this kit as
of today: (2)
"Extra Life" Precision 5K Potentiometers. Picture updated to
include new components.
Update 11/08/09: I'm also including the following items in
this kit as of today: (1) Spacer Bearing, (1) Tube Nyogel 779ZC.
Picture updated to include new components. |
 |
08/22/07: Powder
coated handle assembly. Atari originally painted these with an
automotive type paint, they were not powder coated. Our
process is definitely an upgrade which provides a much better
appearance and function. |
 |
08/22/07: Powder
coated steering assembly. Atari originally painted these with
an automotive type paint, they were not powder coated. Our
process is definitely an upgrade which provides a much better
appearance and function. We were originally going to go with a
nice black zinc plate, but the powder coat looked SO much better, it
was a no-brainer. |
 |
08/22/07: Powder
coated handle assembly cover. Atari originally painted these with an
automotive type paint, they were not powder coated. Our
process is definitely an upgrade which provides a much better
appearance and function. |
 |
09/11/07:
We just finished manufacturing the production run of triggers.
They turned out really nice. Pictured to the left are the very
first three to come out of the molds. Made from black acetal
and machined to spec. These are very tough compared to the
original parts. |
 |
11/17/07: We just
got in a big batch of potentiometers for use with the
controller. These are very nice quality parts and they really
do put the old AB (Allen Bradley) parts to shame! I've never
seen such silky smooth response out of a potentiometer before
these! I'll be using these for every project from here
forward, that's how good they are! |
 |
10/19/08: This is
the first set of picture updates in nearly a year. We got hung
up on the handles early on and it's only now finally getting
resolved. As you can see to the left, this is a completed
pre-production model of the RIGHT handles (inner base and outer
cover). It's made from an aluminum alloy, cast and tapped to spec., and powder coated with a
smooth black satin finish. They turned out beautiful!! |
 |
10/19/08: And
here's the completed pre-production model of the LEFT handles
(inner base and outer cover) as machined and finished. It's made from an aluminum
alloy, cast and tapped to spec.,
and powder coated with a smooth black satin finish. They
turned out beautiful!! BTW, somewhere in the shuffle, we were
able to dig up the original tooling Atari used 15 - 20 years ago!
These are essentially upgraded OEM parts! |
 |
10/19/08: Here's
the completed pre-production models of the whole set of handles (right and left sides)
as cast and finished. Not to sound like a broken record, but
these are made from an aluminum alloy, machined and tapped to spec., and powder coated with a smooth
black satin finish. They turned out beautiful!! Yes, we
used the original tooling that Atari used to make these parts.
Yes, we upgraded the alloy used, but these are essentially OEM parts
for all intents and purposes!
Update 12/04/08: We're going to change these back to MACHINED
handles - the cast parts are just giving us too many problems - from
lousy powder coat and weak material to super-wide tolerance
variances which are simply too inaccurate to allow into the market.
Machined parts will not suffer from ANY of these problems. |
 |
12/01/08: Atari
called out a special damping grease (Nyogel 779) in pretty much ALL
of their old controllers from the 70's and 80's. This is a special silica-thickened, light
viscosity, synthetic hydrocarbon grease intended for mechanical components
that require a light level of damping (noise/chatter reduction).
Anyhow, we ordered a BIG batch of the 779ZC grease to include with
the rebuild kits and to sell individually. This
is the exact same grease called out in Atari specifications with an added moly
lubricant for better aluminum on aluminum lubrication. It also has an
added benefit of quieting down plastic gears! Comes in a 10 gram
tube - enough for several applications. As a side note, we also carry
standard Nyogel 779 (without the "ZC") in 1oz tubes. We
will now include this grease with all levels of yoke rebuild kits at
no additional cost per kit. |
 |
12/04/08 - With all the problems associated with the cast aluminum
handles that we've had to put up with, we've decided to just bite the
bullet and go with our original plan to machine the handles out of solid billet 6061 T6 aluminum
bar stock. This is generally more expensive than casting the parts,
but the machined parts are far superior to their cast counterparts.
With machining, we can control the tolerances within 0.001" which is
simply impossible to do with a casting process. Because of
this, we'll have handles which are precisely matched to each other
(covers and bases will actually fit perfectly). To the left, we have a
Solidworks model of the left-side handle.
The right side is nothing more than a mirror image of the left side,
so we're only showing this one. |
 |
12/04/08 - Here's another view of the Solidworks model of the
left-side handle. The right side is nothing more than a mirror
image of the left side, so we're only showing this one. |
 |
01/11/09: Our order
of special security hex keys just arrived. We're including these
with the controllers when we ship them so the end-user can open up their
controllers and work on them. This extra will included at no
additional cost. |
 |
01/14/09: We've had 75,000ft of this wire sitting in our
warehouse for some time now. I thought I should mention it in the BLOG.
This special 3-conductor wire used in the original controller was a big
concern right from the start of the project. It was probably a
standard wire available in the 80's, but that's not the case now. An exact match for the wire
had proven to be quite difficult, but we didn't give up.
After searching high and low for the exact wire Atari used, we
figured out that it just wasn't going to happen. Why would we
want to use the exact same wire? Well, to put it bluntly, it
was perfect! It was the right size to fit inside of the shafts
without binding up and it was a superior wire type which was capable
of withstanding quite a bit of excessive abuse. Faced with the
inability of sourcing the wire, we opted to contract a local wire
company to produce an exact version of the wire. We
contemplated upgrades, but there was really no need. As it
stands, the OEM wire was perfect in every regard all the way down to the
strand count. Yes, we counted the stands of wire to make sure
we got it right. That's the kind of attention to detail we had
throughout this entire project. This special 3-conductor control wiring
is an exact match for the
OEM wire used by Atari, all the way down to the gauge, color and stand
count. The high strand count makes this wire especially flexible which
is ideal for this application. |
 |
04/14/09 - We just
completed the production run of handles. These are precision machined 6061
T6 aluminum parts. After machining, we tumbled them to clean up
the cut lines which is a great way to prep for painting/powder
coating/anodizing processes. Anyhow, these being machined parts, they
are
VERY
precise when the handle base and cover are fastened together. In
fact, they're within a tolerance of 0.001" which is really tight
compared to the cast aluminum counterparts. The original cast
aluminum parts had an
eye-popping tolerance of 0.250" which is two hundred fifty times more "loose" than
our machined parts. Anyhow, we have enough handles in stock for
about 4800 controllers. We'll never run out of these things!
If we do happen to run out, we'll just make more! Pictured to the
left is a sampling of the RIGHT "Base" |
 |
04/14/09 - Another picture
of the handles. Pictured to the left is a sampling of the RIGHT
"Cover" |
 |
04/14/09 - Another picture
of the handles. Pictured to the left is a sampling of the LEFT
"Base" |
 |
04/14/09 - Another picture
of the handles. Pictured to the left is a sampling of the LEFT
"Cover" |
|
 |
06/24/09: This is the spacer bearing that a few people have
been asking to be included in the rebuild kits. We have had
exactly 1000pcs in stock which was earmarked for use with the
reproduction controllers we intend to release, but we made no
"spares" available....until now. Machined from white Delrin,
these are essentially exact reproduction parts with the exception of
being made from a superior material. The spacer bearing fits
on the steering shaft between the handle assembly frame and the steering assembly
frame. Being an easy part to make and believing that the part wasn't
sought after, we put this part on hold with regard to making extra
parts available for rebuild kits. We will now include them
with all levels of yoke rebuild kits at no additional cost per kit. |
 |
07/05/09: Here's a picture of the very first two
**incomplete** yokes off of the assembly line. They still need
the handles/buttons/triggers to be attached, the wiring installed,
the covers fastened on and a good lube job. Anyhow, these are
the first full reproduction yokes to ever be created since the
originals were made back in the 80's. Ohhh, so nice and shiny!
It's
nice to see these finally being built. We've had the majority
of the components completed and ready to go since mid to late 2007.
The frames in particular have been taking up a LOT of space, being
stored for later use. The project was on track to
release back then, but we got caught up with the handle issues which
caused a huge delay....and
then my subsequent trip to Australia (work related) didn't help matters much. Anyhow,
like I said, it's nice to see this whole project finally coming to a
close.
While
assembling these yokes, I noticed an error in the original BOM
(bill of materials) that Atari supplied. The list calls for
three #6-32 x 5/8" socket cap screws to attach the handle frame to
the steering shaft. Well, that's definitely incorrect -
they're way too long! It should read #6-32 x 3/8"
socket cap screw. Whoops. Luckily, we have plenty of the
correct part in stock, so there will be no hold up caused by this
error. |
 |
07/05/09: Here's another picture of the reproduction yokes.
This one is a close-up of the handle frame. If you will note,
the powder coat really does a good job of providing a slick finish
on the controller frames. I wish it were that simple for the
original CAST handles as we would have been able to complete this
project some time ago. |
 |
07/05/09: Here's one more picture of the reproduction yokes.
This one is a close-up of the steering frame. Pretty much
every last part has a nice snug fit. It's nice to see all of
this precision work finally pay off. |
 |
07/05/09: ....and a side-view close-up. The powder coat
used is a nice semi-gloss. I tried using a satin black finish,
but the finish was too muted for my taste. It was so dull, it
might as well have been a matte finish. I also tried full
gloss....hey, I like bling just as much as the next guy, but full
gloss was TOO MUCH. Semi-Gloss seems to have provided just the
right look I was trying to obtain. |
 |
07/05/09: ....and a side-view wide angle. All of the
gears line up perfectly, all of the shafts line up perfectly....
everything is pretty much perfect, so far!! |
 |
07/05/09: ....one more picture showing the yoke controllers
from the backside. There's a trick to getting those large
torsion springs installed with the anchor pin/nut. It took a
couple of tries before I figured out my groove to get those
assembled quickly. |
 |
07/05/09: ....and one last picture of the pair of controllers
from the front. I was only planning on showing only two or
three pictures at most, but I went snap-happy with the camera and
decided to post all of them here on the BLOG. I hope I
provided enough photos to keep everyone on the edge of their seats
for a while longer. |
 |
07/05/09: Here's a close-up of a reproduction yoke overlay
applied to the cover. We only have the single sample overlay
on-hand at the moment, so we decided to check to make sure it fit
correctly. |
 |
12/14/09: The full production run of Star Wars Yoke overlays
is complete and ready
to go. We now have a relatively small run of 200 units in stock.
We didn't expect to have these completed before the yoke was
released, but as luck would have it we'll be able to offer these
along with the release of the reproduction controller. I
suppose this is a good thing? Anyhow, the overlays are
made from the original Atari films and color matched to original
Atari PMS color specifications. They're adhesive backed and
die cut to a precise fit. These are absolutely perfect
reproduction overlays. |
 |
12/16/09: This is a picture of our special AMP crimping
machines which will make life MUCH easier on this end - no more
blisters from crimping! These are not brand new units, but
they were never used, so they might as well be NEW. One issue,
though: the crimp heads are incorrect. Good news is that we can
remedy the situation quite easily and within a relatively short
period of time. We have access to used parts for this machine. |
 |
12/27/09: All of us here at RAM Controls are pleased to
*finally* announce the full release of the reproduction Star Wars
yoke controller. Over four years in the making, we're thrilled
to offer this product to the market. Nobody else has ever been
able (or willing) to recreate this masterpiece of a controller until
now. A faithful reproduction of the original controller made
by Atari, our model has many transparent upgrades which will ensure
a long-life and trouble free operation.
Reflecting back at our time bringing this project to a reality, we
wrap up this project with relief and excitement.....and perhaps a
little bit of sadness as well. After all, this project has
been the most interesting and talked about subject in our community
for quite some time. All the speculation, all the
anticipation, all the prodding and antagonism -- it's been a
lot of fun, that's for sure!!
Pictured to the left is our very first production model right off
the line. This one is earmarked for our #1 pre-order (you know
who you are). :-) |
 |
12/27/09: I'd like to mention that our 2007 pre-order folks
are getting some special treatment for waiting this our over the
very long haul. Not only are they getting a yoke as promised,
but they're also getting the yoke overlay included (as pictured). |
 |
12/27/09: The yoke frames (handle frame and steering frame)
are both made from 1018 cold rolled steel as mentioned earlier in
the blog. This is a major improvement to the OEM's choice of
HRP&O which stands for (hot rolled pickled and oiled). HRP&O
is very inexpensive and super easy to bend. Those are the
pros. The major con is that it bends TOO easily which makes
for weak structures. |
 |
12/27/09: The yoke overlays as pictured were made using the
original Atari films (graciously provided by Scott Evans of
www.atarigames.com) and the actual work in reproducing the overlays
was done by none other than Rich at www.thisoldgame.com. Our
thanks go to both gentlemen for their superb help in making this
part a reality. |
 |
12/27/09: We are well aware of the pitfalls in making sheet
metal parts, so there was some concern about the frames. After
all, they are made from sheet metal. Maybe with some luck but
even more so our abilities of reverse engineering parts and
correctly drawing them up in a 3D modeling environment, our sheet
metal parts actually came out absolutely perfect. Every last
part lines up with perfection! |
 |
12/27/09: The movement of the steering is so smooth, it's
sick. There's a positive engagement along the full rotation of
the controller. There's nothing sloppy about this controller
-- no way! |
 |
12/27/09: In this photograph, you can see the tie wrap
"anchor" and the grounding clip. Yep, every last piece was
reproduced faithfully. |
 |
12/27/09: From this side, you can see one of the modifications
that was made to the steering frame (to the rear of the yoke
controller). That 3/4" hole actually makes assembly (and
disassembly) of the yoke much easier. |
 |
12/27/09: Here's a close-up view of the steering frame. |
 |
12/27/09: Here's another close-up view of the steering frame. |
 |
12/27/09: This is a wide angle view of the controller from the
rear. It really is a piece of artwork -- so nice to look at. |
 |
12/27/09: Here's a close-up view of the controller from the
rear. |

|
This wraps up our picture supplement for today and officially
brings our project to a close. We may update this blog
additionally to provide more/better pictures of our process from
the beginning and to fill in any blanks we may have
inadvertently left. Thank you everyone for being patient
and allowing us the time needed to get this project completed.
To say that we're relieved is an understatement of the highest
degree. Thank you again, everyone. Enjoy this
masterpiece and use it with confidence that it's another quality
product brought to you by none other than RAM Controls. |

Updates 12/29/06
- David is back from his contract job in TX. All projects have resumed. 01/06/07
- Rescheduled delivery of gears. Changed design of handles from
machined aluminum to cast aluminum alloy. 01/10/07
- First prototype run for handles in process. 01/14/07
- Thumb buttons are completed. They turned out quite nice.
6061 aluminum was used, then hard black anodized. I'm a real big
believer in hard anodizing! 01/20/07
- Received gears. On the surface, everything appears to check out.
I'm going to put these through very thorough testing and see how they
perform. These will be listed for sale as soon as our testing phase
is completed, provided that they pass. Received first
prototype handles. Flaw found with shaft connection outer
radius. Second prototype run for handle in process. 01/21/07
- Handle shaft and steering shaft production started. Grabbed up a
prototype sample of each and included in photos above. As soon as
run is completed, they'll be zinc plated gold.. 02/04/07
- Received second prototype handles. Similar flaw found with shaft
connection outer radius. Almost there. It appears that the
problem resides in the casting process, not the design. Modified
design to offset casting process issues. Third prototype run for the
handles in process.
02/09/07 - This project is still in production
at this point in time. Completion date is estimated to be
approximately 30-60 days. We're near completion of the remainder of
the components and pre-sale has commenced. Pre-sale price will be
targeted at $200. Once the product is completed, retail price will
increase to approximately $250-$260. 02/10/07
- Prototype handle frames and steering frames have been laser cut and are
being prepared for bending/welding. 02/10/07
- The first shipment of custom-made wire has arrived. This is a
dead-on match for the original wire used in Atari's controllers.
It's not made anymore, so we had to contract with a wire manufacturer to
make it for us. We had to agree to purchase fifty 1,500ft
rolls to get them to agree to make this for us. Yes, you counted
that correctly, 75,000 FEET!!
02/17/07 - Prototype handle frames and
steering frames have been welded together and are being sent off for
powder coating. It's coming along s-l-o-w-l-y, but progress is
being made. The frame components look awesome. I've included
some pics of the
pre-production frame assemblies above.
02/20/07 - Prototype handle frames and
steering frames have been approved and the parts are going into full
production. I should have 1000 units cut in a few days. The self
clinching studs used on the steering frame has arrived today, as well.
We're movin' along! 02/23/07
- I just finished up a 1000pc run of the steel hub/collar used in the
handle assembly frame. These are made from 1018CRS material and
are perfect reproduction parts. These are the connection point
between the handle frame and the steering shaft. This is where the
three small socket head screws mount to the main steering shaft.
02/23/07
- Upon further inspection of the gears, we have determined that they are
not going to work out due to inferior build quality. The entire run
has been rejected by yours truly and returned to vendor due to a serious
production flaw. In other words, they were completely unacceptable
and not worthy of inclusion in the reproduction yoke. I'm searching
for an alternate plastic injection molding company to work with me on the
gears. There's always a few backup plans in place, so this shouldn't
cause much trouble.
02/25/07 - Production run QTY of handle frames and steering frames
have been laser cut and is ready for fab (bending/welding).
02/27/07 - The production run of 1000pcs of
handle frames and steering frames have been formed.
03/06/07 - The production run of 1000pcs of
handle frames and steering frames have been welded together.
They're being sent out for powder coating today. 03/12/07
- Here's my first March '07 update. Powder coating is taking longer than anticipated, although it is coming along smoothly.....albeit
slowly. The handles are in production and, again, coming along
slowly. The first batch of controllers are still expected to ship
on-time, however there is a good chance the ship date may get pushed back
due to vendor issues. The vendors have been asked to pull in their
slack and speed things up. Also, a last minute change was made with
regard to the gears. Given the fact that the original vendor failed
to provide quality parts, I chose an alternate vendor. The first
batch of parts are already completed and I'm going to place a large order
based on the results of our inspection process.
03/13/07
- I received a first article on the powder coated frame parts and had to
refuse them for manufacturing flaws. Back to the drawing board for
them. The powder coat vendor can't seem to get the coating just
right. This one turned out very uneven and was totally unacceptable. 03/16/07
- The inspection process for the new sample gears netted an approval
across the board with respect to the 60 tooth, 28 tooth and 14 tooth
gears. Finally, a breath of good news. Note: I'm going
to be relocating at the end of the month, so there may be a few days worth
of delay in news around the beginning of next month. 03/23/07
- I received a first article on the NEXT run of powder coated frame
parts. Again, I had to refuse them for similar manufacturing
flaws. Back to the drawing board for them yet again! Still,
the vendor can't seem to get the coating just right. This one also
turned out very uneven and was totally unacceptable. In fact, in my
humble opinion, this one was worse than the last! 03/27/07
- I received a first article on the latest run of handles. They
finally turned out perfect! I've give the OK to put them into full
production. Once I have them in hand, I'm sending them out for
powder coat at an alternate powder coat vendor given the continued issues
with my current powder coat vendor. 04/01/07
- I'm relocating today. No new news on the yoke project, just wanted
everyone to have a heads up that I may be out of communication for a few
days. 04/08/07
- Ok, I'm back. Relocation has been completed and internet
connection has been restored at new location. Stand by for updates. 04/09/07
- Handles are completed. They turned out quite nice! They're
going off to powder coat with the new vendor. Frame component powder
coat is still failing inspection, therefore alternate powder coat vendor
has been chosen for this task and frame components will be forwarded to
them. Keep fingers crossed! At this point in time, the
completion estimate will not be met, obviously. Pre-orders are still
open, however, anyone who has already pre-ordered is welcome to request a
refund given that I cannot meet the original expected completion date. 04/17/07
- First article on run of powder coated handles has been received. I
am giving this vendor two thumbs up on the workmanship. Absolutely
beautiful! Production run has been OK'd . 04/21/07
- For some reason, the last nine or so updates never published to the
website. Today, all updates from the months of March and April
appear to be on the Star Wars Yoke Project BLOG. To summarize, the
yoke is on hold, awaiting completion of the powder coat process.
What I imagined to be a simple process (IE: powder coating) has turned out
to be a very long tedious endeavor. The vendor I was using for the
powder coat has provided me with at least 5 different versions of a
"completed product" all of which have been refused for various
flaws. I had no other choice but to go with a new vendor which seems
to have been a good decision on my part. I'll update again shortly. 04/27/07
- The production run on the powder coating with the new vendor has begun
and I'm awaiting to approve the first articles on the frame assemblies. 05/04/07
- First article for the frame assemblies from the new vendor received and
rejected. This isn't good news as this is the second vendor I've
assigned to this task and the problem persists. 05/10/07
- Second first article for the frame assemblies from the new vendor
received and rejected again. It looks like this is going to be an
ongoing issue! 05/16/07
- Third first article for the frame assemblies from the new vendor
received and rejected yet again. However, this time it's getting
close. I'm not sure what the real problem is with the powder
coating, but it has something to do with the process itself. The
final parts have been coming out with a very uneven coat with some
portions glossy, some flat, some a little light in color. All in
all, it's been varying too much with regard to quality. This very
last round of samples actually looked much better than all previous
attempts, so we're definitely getting somewhere...finally! It's my
hope that the vendor in question will work out all the kinks during this
next round so I can avoid having to make a tough decision: go with
another vendor or buy the equipment and do it myself...? Keep your
finger crossed.
05/20/07
- Well, it's about time I summarize where we're at with this project so
everyone is in the know. Last time I updated, I mentioned that the
ongoing problems with the powder coating was starting to break free and
looking better. As of today, I am still awaiting the fourth and what
I consider to be the final sampling before I am forced to make a decision
or two. If the next sampling comes back and I can approve of it's
quality, then there's no issue aside from the lengthy wait we've had to
endure. However, if this sampling comes back and I disapprove of it
for any reason related to quality, I'm going to rethink the remainder of
the manufacturing process. Will I continue trying to work with this
vendor or will I find a new one? Will I give up trying to find a
suitable vendor and instead purchase the equipment and apply the finish
in-house? I know this may seem like an easy choice, but it's
not. Having no experience with powder coating, I am reluctant to do
it myself. However, given the extended timeframe involved with
waiting on these vendors and the overall crummy job they've been doing,
I'm tempted to try doing it myself.
In
other news, here's where we are with the remainder of the parts (aside
from the handles and the frame parts at the vendor). All of the
parts are completed and ready. Yep, that's it. The gears, the
wire, the shafts, the bumpers, etc. It's all done....well, almost.
I'm still waiting on an order for some very high quality custom-made
extended life potentiometers, which should arrive around mid-November. Please
watch the order page as most of these items will be added shortly,
including a few different versions of rebuild kits. Stay tuned for
news on this project.
06/01/07
- As promised, I have created three different versions of the Star Wars
yoke rebuild kits. The standard version has all of the common
failure parts (rubber bumpers, gears, switches, thumb buttons, etc.
The deluxe version adds to this the four torsion springs which have been
impossible to source up until now. The premium version adds the
handle and steering shafts, bearings and stop pins. These kits
should keep the community stocked up on parts to keep their existing
controllers maintained for many years to come.
07/18/07
- The fourth and final samples of the handles and frame components look
good. However, I just learned that the samples I have been
receiving and the upcoming production run are made using two completely
different coating methods. This somewhat puts a wrench into things
as I cannot be certain that the final product will resemble in any way
the sample units I have been taking receipt of. I'm going to move
forward and order the full production run of powder coating on the
handles and frame components. I will keep everyone updated on the
progress.
08/11/07
- The second shipment of custom-made wire has arrived.
08/22/07
- I have taken receipt of the first batch of 1000pcs/ea of the powder
coated handle frame, handle frame cover, steering frame and handles. The frame
components look GOOD. However, the handles have turned out quite
awful. I've rejected the entire coat job on the handles and have
kicked them back to the vendor for assessment.
09/07/07
- Apparently, the handles are suffering from something called
"out-gassing" which causes the powder coat to bubble up for lack of a
better way to explain it. I am well aware of this phenomena and
believed I compensated for it by my choice of aluminum alloy. The
process is as follows: preheating the parts, wiping them down, coating
them, baking them in the oven, cooling. However, even with the
preheat/wiping, which is supposed to alleviate the out-gassing issue,
the result is still incorrect. Back to the drawing board!
I'm going to have to get all of the handles bead blasted now!
09/11/07 -
We just finished manufacturing the production run of triggers.
They turned out really nice. We've gone back and forth
between, urethane, aluminum and acetal (delrin) made parts. We
finally settled on acetal since a machined part looks good in this
material and it functions better than original nylon-made parts.
The aluminum parts we tested were too "heavy" and didn't feel quite
right. The urethane parts worked fine, but the finish on them left
a lot to be desired. The acetal parts just seem to be the best all
the way around - they look good and they feel good!
10/14/07
- I just purchased a new powder coating setup for the shop. It's
going to take some time before I take delivery of the equipment.
I've decided that I'm going to work on these handles in-house from here
on forward. This should be an interesting experience.
11/17/07
- The order of custom-made extended life potentiometers arrived today.
I'm going to update the various rebuild kits to include this part.
In the 80's (and 70's for that matter), Atari utilized A-B (Allen
Bradley) Type EJ extra long life potentiometers in their controllers.
These "Type EJ" potentiometers were good parts at the time, nothing else
beat them! They had a rotational life of 1,000,000 cylces opposed
to the 50,000 cycles of their "Type J" version. At some point, A-B
downsized or went out of business and Clarostat ended up taking over
their potentiometer line-up. Today, the potentiometers that
Clarostat offers is a far cry from the original A-B parts of yesteryear.
In fact, they're so unacceptable, I sought out a company who could make
a better part. After extensive research, I found the perfect
company and they were completely capable of making a part which matched
the original A-B specifications. These guys manufacture precision
military grade potentiometers, so I gave them a whirl. It paid off
in a big way! Upon testing the initial samples they produced for
me, I found that their part was actually better in almost every single
area compared to the original Allen Bradley counterpart. The new
parts have the same rotational life (1,000,000 cycles) as the Allen
Bradley part which in itself is an amazing spec, but the resolution and
tracking is simply unbelievable. It's the most "noise-free"
potentiometer I've ever tested. What does this mean when it's all
said and done? It boils down to an extremely smooth operating yoke
controller! Granted, the price for these new potentiometers is
phenomenal, but I've ordered enough of them to bring the pricing down to
a point where it has become a feasible option for this (and other)
projects here at RAM Controls. I can't wait to put these parts
into regular use!
11/22/07
- We now have our very own in-house
powder coating capabilities. With some luck, this should speed things
along with the SW Yoke project.
12/01/07
- Our initial attempts at using the
powder coating equipment has been met with some difficulties, namely the lack of
gas utility here at the shop. We're working on it. Stay tuned.
12/03/07
- Just finished up bead blasting the handles and I'm going to try and
run them through the powder coat process again. I'm hopeful that
this powder coating issue will be resolved sometime soon. This one
process is all that is holding up the entire project.
12/15/07
- All projects at RAM Controls are temporarily shut down while David
is working a contract in Australia. The Star Wars yoke projects will resume in
mid-January. Stay tuned..
01/12/08
- RAM Controls projects are now back
into production. The project duties are designated to Jeremy, Bob, Jeff
and Craig.
01/14/08
- We took receipt of the powder coating equipment in November. The
"oven" is much larger than I had expected, but I found a place for it in
the shop. The downside is that it runs on gas and I don't have gas
service to the shop. I've called up the utility and scheduled a
time/day for them to come out and make an assessment for me.
01/19/08 - I had our
casting vendor run off several handle samples using six different
aluminum alloys and two zinc alloys. Since I don't have my powder
coating equipment set up and running yes, I'm going to run these by our
current vendor and see what kind of results I can get.
02/24/08 - I'm
getting good results with all the alloys except for one of them.
One alloy in particular did extremely well. I'm going to consider
using this alloy and move forward. If I had known all the issues
related to powder coating and reactions with certain alloys, I could
have saved myself so much time!
03/15/08
- It looks like the Star Wars yoke project is finally
coming to a close. The powder coating issues appear to have been overcome once
and for all with our new powder coating equipment. The handle assembly frame and the steering assembly frame
were already completed back in late August '07 but the handles have been
an ongoing issue ever since. We've gone through many, many power
coat processes and determined that the alloy in use was the problem.
However, I've had some excellent results with the original alloy on OUR
equipment. I'm going to run off a larger batch and see what
happens.
03/18/08 - This
project has taken far longer than originally anticipated. If you
have a pre-order with us for this item and you feel that you can wait no
longer, please don't hesitate to contact us for a full refund.
Please accept our apologies for this lengthy completion time.
03/20/08 - The third
shipment of custom-made wire has arrived.
03/29/08
- We're prepping the handles for powder coating. We should begin
the process in a week or so.
04/08/08
- We have begun the powder coat
process on the Star Wars yoke handles in-house. Stay tuned for updates.
04/21/08
- It seems that the issues with the powder coating
persist with the handles. The coat produced is uneven. After having
discussing the matter, we believe that our original assessment was correct and
that it has everything to do with the original alloy, no matter who coats it! Further testing must be performed in order to
determine exactly why we continue to have issues with the coat process on the
handles. I really don't want to have to go through the expense of running
a whole new set of handles with a new alloy. I will, however, if nothing
else provides perfect results for me. Stay tuned for more information.
05/01/08
- We are developing our own in-house made yoke decals (in Star Wars,
Empire Strikes Back, and Return of the Jedi flavors) to go along with
the yoke controller. Stay tuned for more information.
05/20/08 - We have
taken receipt of a second order of the custom made potentiometers, both
in 5K and 120K. Originally, we were going to order 100K for MAME
use, but some last minute second-guessing netted us 120K pots.
We're developing our own USB/PS2 interface for the Star Wars yoke and
the 120K pots seem to perform better. I'm hoping that users of
other interfaces can use the 120K pots, too.
06/15/08 - We are
developing our own in-house made control panels to complement the yokes.
We're starting with Star Wars cockpit control panels and will move to
Star Wars upright control panels thereafter.
06/20/08
- The Star Wars yoke project has
been stalled yet again because of the powder coating. In April '08 we
entertained the idea that maybe the alloy we used was at fault and, after much
testing, we determined that this was in fact the issue at hand. After two
months of trial and error, we've chosen a new alloy for the handles which is
both stronger (a lot stronger) than the OEM handle material and does not react
poorly with the powder coating. We will now begin the process of creating a
small sampling of the handles with the new alloy and powder coat them.
Essentially, this project is approximately 85% completed at this time.
07/04/08
- All projects at RAM Controls are temporarily shut down while David
is working a contract in Australia. Projects will resume in about 1 week
while project management is reassigned. Stay tuned..
07/11/08
- All of the projects have been resumed as of
07/09/08. The sample Star Wars yoke handles
manufactured from the new alloy material have been completed. We're going
to powder coat them and will have results shortly. Stay tuned.
07/14/08
- The powder coat testing on the new
Star Wars yoke handles appears to have been successful. We're going to let
the coat sit for a awhile to see if there is any delayed reaction before we
officially call this issue resolved. Stay tuned.
07/18/08
- A short note to let everyone know that our fourth and final shipment
of custom-made three conductor wire has arrived. We now have
enough stock of this wire to cover the manufacture well over 7000
yokes! We're in good shape!
07/22/08
- It's been a little over a week now
and the Star Wars yoke handles manufactured with the new alloy appear to have
accepted the powdercoat without incident. Production run of the new alloy
handles will begin shortly. We have to shop this part out to a casting
vendor, so it may take awhile. The casting industry appears to have been
unaffected by the economic downturn which means they're busier than ever.
Stay tuned for more information on this topic.
07/24/08
- Note: there are only a few Star
Wars yoke pre-orders remaining. We would like to again mention that if you
have a pre-order for this item and you no longer wish to wait for our
reproduction version of the Star Wars yoke to be completed, contact our sales
department and they will issue a full refund to you. Please accept our
apologies for the continued delay with this project.
08/15/08
- Again, we would like to mention
that if you have an existing pre-order for the Star Wars yoke and you no longer
wish to wait for our reproduction version to be completed, contact our sales
department and they will issue a full refund to you. Please accept our
apologies for the continued delay with this project.
08/23/08
- Star Wars yoke
handle casting is still in process. We placed the order a month ago, so
we're in the queue. The good news is that the casting mold has already
been made previous to the alloy change and it will work fine with the new
production run. So, we'll save a little bit of time there.
08/24/08
- While our ordering system is offline, if anyone wishes to purchase our
yoke rebuild kits or individual parts, please visit
www.videogameparts.com. They carry all of our
reproduction parts.
09/18/08
- The Star Wars yoke handles are still
in process as of today. We're still in the queue to get the parts cast
from the new alloy. Again, refunds are still available to any existing
pre-order customers. Contact sales for any assistance.
09/21/08 - We just
got word that our sample parts will be run in the next week or so.
We should have the samples by early next month.
10/09/08
- Star Wars handle cast samples just
came in today. These samples turned out perfect! It appears that our
new choice of aluminum alloy is working out great. It is stronger than the
OEM material and it lends itself to a good powder coat with negligible outgas
issues. Just waiting to sign this off before the full production run
begins.
10/12/08 - We coated the samples and we're letting them sit for a
few days. If all goes as planned, we should have pictures in about
a week.
10/19/08 - Pictures
of most recent yoke handle samples have been added to the BLOG.
The samples turned out quite nice. Our production units should
appear similar or better than these.
11/21/08 - We're
still behind schedule, but we're plugging away. All we're waiting
on are those handles to finish up at the casting plant before we coat
them and complete the project.
11/23/08 - The Star
Wars project BLOG has been updated to include all of the
notes/news/photos since the last update.
12/01/08 - Atari
called out a special damping grease (Nyogel 779) in pretty much ALL
of their old controllers from the 70's and 80's. This is a special silica-thickened, light
viscosity, synthetic hydrocarbon grease intended for mechanical components
that require a light level of damping (noise/chatter reduction).
Anyhow, we ordered a BIG batch of the 779ZC grease to include with
the rebuild kits and to sell individually. This
is the exact same grease called out in Atari specifications with an added moly
lubricant for better aluminum on aluminum lubrication. It also has an
added benefit of quieting down plastic gears! Comes in a 10 gram
tube - enough for several applications. As a side note, we also carry
standard Nyogel 779 (without the "ZC") in 1oz tubes. We
will now include this grease with all levels of yoke rebuild kits at no
additional cost per kit.
12/04/08 - This
project has been continuously riddled with issues revolving around the
handles and the fact that they're made from cast aluminum. We just
received the latest samples from the *latest* initial production run and
they're inferior. The halves (cover/base) do not align properly.
This is normal for a cast aluminum part, but the magnitude of the flaw
is simply too much to be allowed to pass. Not only that, but
when powder coating the handles, they inevitably fail inspection due to outgassing - this has been an ongoing issue for some time now. It
seems that cast aluminum parts are simply junk! This reproduction
project deserves nothing less than the best with regard to manufacturing
quality. With that in mind, it's been decided to drop the idea of
having these handles cast and just machine them from solid billet
aluminum bar stock. It's more costly and labor intensive, but we
will get precise parts that are exactly matched pairs (covers/bases).
12/09/08 - To save
on material cost, we're putting together an aluminum extrusion tool for
the handle bases. This will get us length of material which
has a similar profile as the part itself so there's less machine time
involved and less material waste. We'll be able to cut material
cost in half. Since we make our own tooling in-house, the cost for
tooling itself is negligible. In fact, it's such a good deal, we
can cut the cost of a machined part (which is far superior to a cast
part) to a price which is significantly lower than the cast aluminum
parts we were having made. This is good because we can increase
quality of the controller while holding the price level which means no
price increase!
12/15/08 - We just
finished up the aluminum extrusion tooling and we're sending it out to
have material run for us.
12/20/08 - We've
just received enough extruded aluminum to make roughly 5000 handle
bases. We'll be using standard off the shelf aluminum bar stock
for the handle covers. We're about to
01/05/09 - Our very
first prototype machined handle bases and covers are completed.
We're looking them over right now and expect to have a decision made on
whether or not they're acceptable as-is or if they need to go back for
revision. They appear to match up/align with each other perfectly.
01/07/09 - We
decided to revise three features on the handle bases. These
features are considered manufacturing upgrades, nothing more. The covers
were approved with no issues noted.
01/10/09 - Our
second set of prototype machined handles have been completed.
We're reworking those new design features at this point in time.
01/11/09 - Our order
of special security hex keys just arrived. We're including these
with the controllers when we ship them so the end-user can open up their
controllers and work on them. This extra will included at no
additional cost.
01/14/09 -
We've had 75,000ft of the special custom made control cable sitting
in our warehouse for some time now. We've been experimenting with
the wire and noticed that it's quite difficult to work with. The
jacket on it is actually somewhat picky about how it's stripped off.
If not careful, it seems that the wires inside are easily damaged.
We've been doing a LOT of testing and we cannot seem to find a
dependable (and repeatable) method to strip the cable. After going
through at least 10 different type/brand of wire strippers, we're
looking into a custom solution. Anyhow, I just wanted to bring
this up in case it becomes an issue later on down the road.
Originally, the 3-conductor wire used in the original controller was a big
concern right from the start of the project, but the problem back
then was just trying to match it with something available now. An exact match for the wire
had proven to be quite difficult, but we didn't give up.
After searching high and low for the exact wire Atari used, we
figured out that it just wasn't going to happen. Why would we
want to use the exact same wire? Well, to put it bluntly, it
was perfect! It was the right size to fit inside of the shafts
without binding up and it was a superior wire type which was capable
of withstanding quite a bit of excessive abuse. Faced with the
inability of sourcing the wire, we opted to contract a local wire
company to produce an exact version of the wire. We
contemplated upgrades, but there was really no need. As it
stands, the OEM wire was perfect in every regard all the way down to the
strand count. Yes, we counted the stands of wire to make sure
we got it right. That's the kind of attention to detail we had
throughout this entire project. This special 3-conductor control wiring
is an exact match for the
OEM wire used by Atari, all the way down to the gauge, color and stand
count. The high strand count makes this wire especially flexible which
is ideal for this application.
01/26/09 - We're
working on a value-added device for the yoke controller - a USB adapter.
This will be designed as a plug-and-play device which will work on any
standard windows system which recognizes generic HID USB devices.
More to come later.
01/30/09 - We just
got word that Dave's contract has concluded and he'll be back in the
States shortly at which time he'll be taking over all of the RAM
Controls projects once again.
02/04/09 - It's
confirmed, David is back from his contract in Australia and it looks
like he's back to stay! He's the lead on all RAM Controls projects
from this point forward.
02/09/09 - Our third
set of prototype machined handles have been completed. We have
approved the bases this time as-is. We're committing to a full
production run at this point in time.
02/17/09 - While
waiting for two of the milling centers to free up, we've made some minor
changes to the corner radii on the handles to help increase it's
strength. These changes don't require any further prototype runs,
so we can go straight into production as soon as the machines are free.
02/28/09 - The full
production run of machined handles has commenced as of today. We
should have these completed sometime in early to mid April, depending on
machine usage.
03/02/09 - It feels
like we're off to a slow start this year, overall, but things are
definitely happening. The handles are in process and we finally
have a version that isn't going to fail a quality inspection for a
change! After this experience, I'll never go back to having a part
made from cast aluminum. Who needs that kind of headache?
Anyhow, like I said, the handles are in process and we've got pretty
much every other part of the controller completed and ready to go.
We're still having issues with the wire, but we're working on that.
I'm hopeful that we will have these controllers out the door by the end
of October or November of this year. At the very least, before
Christmas!! Now that I am back in the saddle over here, I should
be able to make those tough decisions that everyone else was afraid to
while I was away. Stay tuned for more information.
03/21/09 - Another
note on the USB adapter. We have our first prototype USB adapter
in hand and it looks good. It's based on a Microchip brand
microcontroller and it's designed to be a simple plug-and-play device.
04/04/09 - We have
another milling machine that just became available to us as far as
machine time goes, so I'm running more handles on this one so I can
close up the gap. I'm trying to meet that April deadline I set for
myself on this.
04/11/09 - It's
settled, we're going to provide a full range of yoke overlays for these
controllers: Star Wars upright, Star Wars cockpit (yep, there is a
difference), Empire Strikes Back, Return of the Jedi, Firefox upright,
Firefox cockpit. We may not have any of the overlays available
until sometime after we release the yoke controllers. However, the
first overlays which we intend to release will be the Star Wars upright
and cockpit versions.
04/14/09 - We just
completed the production run of handles. These are precision machined 6061
T6 aluminum parts. After machining, we tumbled them to clean up
the cut lines which is a great prep for painting/powder
coating/anodizing processes. Anyhow, these being machined parts, they look
VERY
precise when the handle base and cover are fastened together. In
fact, they're within a tolerance of 0.001" which is really tight
compared to the cast aluminum counterparts. The original cast
aluminum parts had an
eye-popping tolerance of 0.250" which is two hundred fifty times more "loose" than
our machined parts. Anyhow, we have enough handles in stock for
about 4800 controllers. We'll never run out of these things!
If we do happen to run out, we'll just make more! Pictured to the
left is a sampling of the RIGHT "Base"
04/22/09 - A few
pieces of the handles have been sent out for finishing. Since we
have nice machined parts now, I'm testing out powder coating, hard
anodizing and painting so I can determine the best option. Each
process has it's pros and cons.
05/05/09 - The
anodized parts are back in our hands as of today. They look really
GOOD, but I'm not going to make a decision until I see the powder coated
parts and the painted parts. BTW, the painted parts are being done
with "hardened" paint like the kind used on vehicles - gives it a really
tough finish. I'm concerned about each process for different
reasons, but I have to admit that these hard anodized handles look
REALLY nice!! If there was no other process available, I would
approve these in a heartbeat. Compared to the powder coated CAST
aluminum parts, it's like night and day between the two type.
Hopefully, I'll get better results from the powder coating on the
machined handles.
05/10/09 - All
right, now we're getting somewhere. The painted handles and the
powder coated handles are finally in my hands as of today. Looking
them over, I do like the finish on both. The painted finish,
however, seems to be prone to damage/scratches pretty easily, so it's
got a thumbs down. Now, the powder coated handles are a different
story. They look nice....very nice, indeed. In fact, they
look nothing like the powder coated cast aluminum parts we ran in the
past. However, I do have a concern about the thickness of the
coat. It seems like it varies between 0.002" and 0.005" which may
not seem like much, but that kind of variance can bind up the
countersinks on the handle base. I'm going to see if the powder
coat people can control that a little better. If not, I'm
definitely leaning toward hard anodizing the handles.
05/25/09 - I had
another set of handles powder coated and they were able to tighten up
the tolerances on the thickness, but it still varies a bit too much for
my liking. I'll try one more time. If they can't control the
variance anymore, I'll probably go with hard anodizing as my choice.
Besides, a thick hard anodize is actually tougher than powder coating to
begin with. However, the sleek finish of powder coating can look
better than a hard anodize. Decisions, decisions!
06/10/09 - I just
got back the last set of powder coated machined handles I intend to
test. This set looks exactly like the last set. Honestly,
I'm torn between the powder coated parts and the hard anodized parts.
Unless I change my mind before I run them, I'll just have the handles
hard anodized. They really do look very nice and I think it's a
good choice.
06/24/09 - People
have been asking for the spacer bearing to be included in the rebuild
kits. We have had exactly 1000pcs in stock which was earmarked for
use with the reproduction controllers we intend to release, but we
didn't make any "spares" available....until now. While I wait for
things to move along, I've had a big batch of spare spacer bearings
made. Machined from white Delrin, these are essentially exact
reproduction parts with the exception of being made from a superior
material. The spacer bearing fits on the steering shaft between
the handle assembly frame and the steering assembly
frame. Being an easy part to make and believing that the part wasn't
sought after, we put this part on hold with regard to making extra parts
available for rebuild kits. We will now include them with all
levels of yoke rebuild kits at no additional cost per kit.
07/05/09 - We have
officially begun assembly of the controllers as of today. We have
enough parts for 1000 units, but we're going to assemble only half of
those for now. I think that 500 of these should last us a very
long time, unless demand for these is much higher than expected.
As a side note, the sheet metal used to make 1000 Star Wars yokes weighs
approximately 5600lbs. That's almost THREE TONS! Most people
don't know just how much steel can weigh. I was reminded of this
fact just recently when I had to move the material by myself. Talk
about a back breaker!
07/15/09 - Assembly
has been going well. So far we have approximately 200 units
assembled, minus the wiring, insertion of the buttons/triggers in the
handles and application of the Nyogel damping grease.
07/20/09 - Things
are moving along at a good pace. We have 400 of the yoke
controllers assembled at this time. We're still stuck on the
wiring which is holding us up on completing the assembly, but we hope to
get around this promptly.
08/07/09 - We've
mostly assembled all 500 of the initial run except for the final touches
(grease, buttons, triggers, wiring, covers). These take up a lot
of room, much more than the unassembled parts do. I'd like
to get these fully assembled ASAP so I can start boxing them up for
shipping and proper storage.
08/20/09 - We're in
a holding pattern for the time being, trying to get around this wiring
issue. In the meantime, we're trying to work on all the value
added stuff for the Star Wars yoke (USB, yoke overlays, etc).
08/27/09 - The idea
of a USB-only version of the controller has been brought up. We
can easily modify the yoke to mount a USB board directly on the
controller itself and have it permanently wired up as such. This
way, a USB cable could be plugged into the controller and plug-and-play
connectivity without the messy wires or conversion harness, etc.
Any input on this subject will be appreciated. Contact
sales@ram-controls.com
with your comments and suggestions.
09/01/09 - We're now
working with a tool maker who specializes in wire stripping tools and
machines. We've done a lot of back and forth to try and determine
if they have anything existing which will work perfectly with what we
have, but we're unsure as of now. We're awaiting one of their
catalogs.
09/13/09 - We have
decided that there is no existing wire stripper or machine which will
specifically work (correctly) with our custom made wire. We've
figured out a work-around that gives us a 50/50 chance at a good strip,
but that's not very good odds when you consider the cost of this custom
wire. We'll keep working with this tool maker and see if they can
help....and at what cost.
09/29/09 - We've
sent off sample wire/cable to the manufacturer so they can get the
precise measurements they need to cut the tools for us. These
custom made wire strippers should resolve our issue with stripping the
wire.
10/05/09 - The
tool maker got back to us and confirmed that our custom made wire is
very difficult to work with. They're giving us a few options for
different types of strippers that they can custom design for us.
It ranges from $50 hand tools to $20,000 automated machines. We're
opting for a few of the $50 tools. They should have a prototype
tool (not an actual production tool) ready for us to evaluate in a week
or two.
10/17/09 - We just
received our test wire stripper tool and it seems to work. It
looks like a pair of wacky scissors a-la Edward Scissorhands!
Anyhow, we tried them out a few dozen times to test repeatability and it
looks like we're a go! We've given the manufacturer the OK and
placed the order for five sets. At no point when I was sourcing the
custom wire did I ever consider that we would need special wire strippers for
it!
10/19/09 -While
doing all this work with the wire, everyone involved has developed
blisters on their hands from overuse of the hand crimpers we've been
using. Obviously, this isn't going to fly, so I'm looking into
something automated. I know that Amp sells a line of devices just
for this type of situation. I'll be calling them shortly to find
out my options.
10/22/09 - After
speaking with AMP, it looks like my options are limited to a few very
pricey crimping machines. I happen to like the Amp-O-Lectric Model
G the most out of everything I've researched. However, they cost
quite a bit. I'm on the search for a deal on a used machine.
10/25/09 - I found a
sweet deal on a crimping machine. The best part is that the
machine is brand new and I'm getting it in trade for NO CASH out of
pocket. I could not have asked for a better deal. Now
there's the waiting for it to arrive!
10/26/09 - We're a
little slowed up on the assembly procedure - the wiring is giving us
some grief as it does not strip easily and this has introduced a new
hiccup in this lengthy project. This issue has already been
brought up and we have a solution in the works, but we still don't have
that solution in-hand just yet. However, we should be able to
assemble a few controllers and get them out to the very first pre-orders
so they can have a first hand look at the finished product!
10/27/09 - We're
putting the USB adapter through some final testing before we release it.
We found two small firmware issues we're attempting to correct before we
assemble and ship these. Hardware wise, the product is perfect.
10/29/09 - I know
I'm going to take some flak for this, but it looks like we're going to
have to push back the release date a little bit. We're all but
finished, but this problem with the wiring is serious enough that I want
to make sure it's done correctly. I'm working quickly to overcome
the issue and get these 99% completed controllers out the door.
Everyone, just hold on a little longer. Nobody in the history of
reproduction work has ever tackled the Star Wars yoke controller like I
have and all of my hard work (although, it's taken far too long) is
going to net a perfect replacement controller in the very near future.
Sit tight!!
11/05/09 - Alright,
I've got a solid plan in motion. I've already ordered a few sets
of the special wire strippers and crimpers to speed things along.
The wire strippers are custom designed for this exact wire type (since
it's a custom wire in the first place) which will cut the jacket off
without damaging the wires inside. The crimper is actually a
high-end Amp-O-Lectric (Model G) made to automate wire crimping to some
degree. These run $15K new, but we found a good deal on a used one
which we're getting in trade (no cash!). Anyhow, we should have
the device in our hands shortly. I've also got a few contract
workers prepped and ready to go when all of the equipment is in so we
can pump these controllers out quickly.
11/13/09 - We
received the special custom made wire strippers today, so we started the
process of prepping the cabling for the controllers. We're still
awaiting the delivery of the Amp-O-Lectric crimping machine, but we're
prepping for it's arrival in the meantime.
11/14/09 - The
controller project is finally coming to a close. I know I've said
this before, but I see nothing that's standing in the way of getting
this project completed now, except for the slow assembly time (waiting
on the Amp-O-Lectric crimper). We have all of the parts necessary
to build the controllers, the parts are finished (painted/powdercoated)
without issue and we worked out all the bugs with the wiring process
itself - just need to get that last tool in. It's only a matter of
time before we have these controllers released to market. As
planned before, we're going to release a few at a time until all of the
pre-orders are taken care of and then we'll move into full sales.
11/22/09 - Enough
wire has been cut and stripped for 1000 yokes. We're still waiting
on the Amp-O-Lectric machine to arrive.
11/30/09 - We're now
a month past our last official release date and here we are with mostly
complete controllers sitting and ready for the wiring to be crimped
together. Hopes are high for a before-Christmas release, but I'm
not going to hold my breath at this point.
12/14/09 -
We have a relatively small run of 200 Star Wars yoke overlays in
stock as of today. Because of the way we planned everything
(staggered), we did not expect to have the yoke overlays ready anywhere
near the release date of the yoke controller. In fact, the release
date was supposed to be about 4-6 month AFTER the release of the yoke
controller itself. However, due to the numerous delays involved
with completing the yoke controller, the yoke overlays ended up getting
finished first. Overall, this is actually a good development.
Now we'll be able to supply yoke overlays immediately during/after the
purchase of a yoke controller. The overlays are made from the
original Atari films and color matched to original Atari PMS color
specifications. They're then adhesive backed and die cut to a
precise fit. These really are absolutely perfect reproduction
overlays.
12/16/09 - The
Amp-O-Lectric crimping machines have arrived, but the heads are
incorrect. Figures. We're getting that remedied NOW.
BTW, yes I said "machines". We were expecting to get only ONE of
the two available machines, but somehow we ended up with BOTH of them!
Nice!!
12/21/09 - The new
crimping heads arrived this morning. We're getting the machines
setup and testing them today. With some luck and lots of finger
crossing, we might very well have our first few reproduction controllers
shipped this week or next. We're SO close to having this done!!!
Hold onto your seats, everyone!!
12/27/09 - All of us here at RAM Controls are pleased to
*finally* announce the full release of the reproduction Star Wars
yoke controller. Over four years in the making, we're thrilled
to offer this product to the market. Nobody else has ever been
able (or willing) to recreate this masterpiece of a controller until
now. A faithful reproduction of the original controller made
by Atari, our model has many transparent upgrades which will ensure
a long-life and trouble free operation.
Reflecting back at our time bringing this project to a reality, we
wrap up this project with relief and excitement.....and perhaps a
little bit of sadness as well. After all, this project has
been the most interesting and talked about subject in our community
for quite some time. All the speculation, all the
anticipation, all the prodding and antagonism -- it's been a
lot of fun, that's for sure!!
This wraps up our blog and officially
brings our project to a close. We may update this blog
additionally to provide more/better pictures of our process from
the beginning and to fill in any blanks we may have
inadvertently left. Thank you everyone for being patient
and allowing us the time needed to get this project completed.
To say that we're relieved is an understatement of the highest
degree. Thank you again, everyone. Enjoy this
masterpiece and use it with confidence that it's another quality
product brought to you by none other than RAM Controls.
|